The Absolute Best Cake in Costa Mesa CA [Updated 2025]

Along the way, I’ve indulged in countless sweet slices and decadent treats, sampling cakes that range from classic to avant-garde. After scouring the city and savoring every crumb, I’ve narrowed it down to five top locations that truly stand out.

You can trust my taste buds—I’ve been on a quest for the perfect cake for years, always on the lookout for that magical balance of flavor, texture, and presentation. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just treating yourself (because why not?), I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find Costa Mesa’s finest confections. Let’s dive into this delicious journey together!

Broken Yolk Cafe

When I walked into Broken Yolk Cafe, the first thing that struck me was the inviting atmosphere—bright, cheerful, and buzzing with energy. The attentive staff welcomed me with warm smiles, setting the tone for a delightful meal. While this popular spot is renowned for its delectable breakfast and lunch offerings, I couldn't help but investigate their cake selection for my quest for the best cake in Costa Mesa.

I opted to try their signature dessert, the Carrot Cake. Wow! It was an absolute treat—moist, fluffy, and generously garnished with rich cream cheese frosting. Each bite was a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate, making it a tempting finale to my meal. Although this cafe is mostly known for its scrumptious breakfast options, the dessert certainly deserves a spotlight.

To top off my experience, I couldn’t resist ordering a refreshing Bloody Mary, which paired perfectly with their famous Eggs Benedict. The service was fast and efficient, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of perfect. If you find yourself in Costa Mesa and have a craving for cake amidst a wonderful breakfast, Broken Yolk Cafe is a sweet destination that definitely delivers!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Mesa.

Lesley's Creative Cakes, Flowers & Catering

At Lesley’s Creative Cakes, my taste buds threw a party! The vanilla bean cake I chose was a delightful dream, with its moist texture and rich flavor dancing on my palate. The elegant design, adorned with delicate floral accents, proved that this bakery excels at both taste and artistry. Each slice was a generous portion, and the subtle sweetness of the frosting complemented the cake perfectly—not overly sweet, just right.

Lesley’s passion for baking shines through every creation, making this charming spot a must-visit for cake enthusiasts. If you're in Costa Mesa, don’t miss out on this delicious gem!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Chandler.

Bahama Buck's - Mesa (E Southern Avenue)

Nestled in the sunny vibe of Costa Mesa, Bahama Buck's isn't just about refreshing treats—it's a hidden gem for cake lovers! I sampled their dreamy tropical cake, a delightful blend of moist coconut and tangy pineapple, topped with an airy frosting that transports your taste buds straight to paradise. The presentation was as vibrant as the colorful surroundings, making each slice a feast for the eyes. With a playful atmosphere and friendly service, this spot is perfect for a casual dessert escape. If you're on the hunt for a cake that radiates joy, don’t miss this tropical treasure!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Bahama Buck's - Mesa S Signal Butte Road

During my delightful visit to Bahama Buck's - Mesa S Signal Butte Road in Costa Mesa, CA, I was greeted by an explosion of tropical flavors that proved it’s more than just a shaved ice shop. While their cakes might not steal the spotlight, the fluffy, coconut-tinged slice I tried was a sweet surprise! Each bite offered a creamy delight that reminded me of sun-soaked beaches. The ambiance was lively, encouraging conversations over treats. If you find yourself craving a cake with a beachy twist, this whimsical spot definitely deserves a visit! A hidden gem worth the venture!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Scottsdale.

Bahama Buck's

During my visit to Bahama Buck's in Costa Mesa, I was greeted by a tropical vibe that immediately lifted my spirits. Their signature cake, a delightful coconut cream masterpiece, was a slice of paradise! The fluffy texture and rich coconut flavor danced harmoniously on my palate. Topped with light whipped cream and toasted coconut, each bite felt like a mini getaway. While they are renowned for their shaved ice, their cake deserves special mention too! If you're in the mood for a cake that’s both decadent and refreshingly unique, Bahama Buck's is a paradise worth cherishing.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gilbert.