Tempe's Best NY Pizza [Updated 2026]

You know, there’s nothing quite like that first bite of a perfectly crafted New York-style pizza—thin, crispy crust, gooey cheese, and those toppings that just dance on your taste buds. After diving into 12 top spots in Tempe, I’ve uncovered some hidden gems and fan favorites that will make any pizza lover’s heart skip a beat.

With years of tasting and critiquing under my belt, I’ve developed a discerning palate that helps me spot the real deal. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, trust me—you won’t want to miss out on these slices of heaven. So, let’s dig into the pizza scene and find out where you can grab that ultimate pie!

Spinato's Pizzeria and Family Kitchen

Highlights
Friendly and helpful service
Nice atmosphere with big windows
Great for family events
Beautiful outdoor balcony
Delicious gelato and garlic bread

Nestled in the heart of Tempe, Spinato's Pizzeria and Family Kitchen is a delightful spot that truly captures the essence of New York-style pizza. Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the friendly and helpful service—it felt like I was greeted by friends rather than staff. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, accentuated by big windows that let in the lovely Arizona sunshine.

Now, let’s talk pizza! Spinato’s offers a delicious array of toppings atop a beautifully crafted crust, with just the right amount of chewiness and crisp. Every bite transports you to the bustling streets of New York, making it hard to resist ordering another slice.

For those dining with family, this place holds an edge, boasting a great vibe for family events. Just imagine sharing a large pie while basking in the laughter of loved ones around you. And don’t forget to indulge in their incredible gelato and garlic bread afterwards—an unbeatable finish to a fantastic meal!

In my quest for the best NY pizza in Tempe, Spinato’s surely hits the mark, making it a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Crust Pizzeria Tempe

Highlights
Amazing Spicy Knots
Fresh Quality Toppings
Superb Garlic Chicken Wings
Perfect Cannoli for Dessert
Convenient Movie Theater Location

Crust Pizzeria Tempe is a delightful gem tucked away in a lively location near a movie theater. As I stepped inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and melting cheese enveloped me like a warm hug, signaling that I was in for a treat. Their spicy knots are an absolute must-try; perfectly baked and served piping hot, they delivered just the right punch to kick off my meal.

Now, let’s talk toppings! Crust takes quality to heart. Each slice is generously adorned with fresh ingredients that practically dance off the crust. I opted for their garlic chicken pizza, which was bursting with flavor and hit that perfect balance between savory and satisfying.

But the adventure didn’t end there—I couldn’t resist pairing my pizza feast with their superb garlic chicken wings. Each bite was a tantalizing explosion of flavors, making them some of the best wings I’ve tasted. And for a sweet finish, their cannoli was like a dreamy embrace after a hearty meal.

Overall, Crust Pizzeria is a top contender in the Tempe pizza scene, delivering not just delicious food but a playful vibe that makes each visit special. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Scottsdale.

Johnny T's Brooklyn Pizzeria

Highlights
Authentic New York experience
Excellent sauce and cheese
Amazing undercarriage
Friendly owner and great service
Nostalgic atmosphere

From the moment I stepped into Johnny T's Brooklyn Pizzeria, I was whisked away to the streets of New York. The nostalgic atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm embrace, as photographs of the Big Apple adorned the walls. But let’s talk about the pizza! The first slice I tasted was proof that this spot boasts an authentic New York experience.

The sauce and cheese were a wondrous symphony in my mouth—rich and tangy, with just the right amount of stretch and bite. I must commend their amazing undercarriage; the crust managed to strike that perfect balance between crispy and chewy, able to withstand its toppings without flopping over.

Moreover, the owner’s friendly banter made my visit even more enjoyable; it felt like I was catching up with an old friend. The service was prompt, yet warm, showcasing the heart of a true neighborhood pizzeria.

In the realm of Tempe's pizza landscape, Johnny T's is a delightful gem. For anyone looking to indulge in top-notch NY pizza, I wholeheartedly recommend giving them a try. This place has definitely earned a spot on my pizza pilgrimage map! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gilbert.

Bella Gusto Urban Pizzeria

Highlights
Amazing friendly service
Cute and welcoming atmosphere
Delicious bread and pizza
Great dessert options
Perfect for date nights

Walking into Bella Gusto Urban Pizzeria feels like a warm invitation from an old friend. The atmosphere is both charming and inviting, with a cozy vibe that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. The moment I settled in, I was greeted by a team whose friendly service truly brightened my day.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! The deliciousness of their NY-style pies is nothing short of remarkable. The crust has that perfect balance of crispness and chew—a finely tuned symphony of texture. Each bite was a heavenly dance of flavors, with the right amount of sauce and cheese that left me savoring every morsel.

And how could I resist trying the desserts? The selection had my sweet tooth doing a happy jig. For those seeking a fun spot for date nights, this pizzeria is an excellent choice. If you're in Tempe and craving the essence of NY pizza, then Bella Gusto Urban Pizzeria is a must-visit. Treat yourself—you won’t be disappointed! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Chandler.

Amici Pizza

Highlights
NY Style Pizza
Delicious Garlic Knots
Appetizing Wings
Long Waits Expected
Friendly Service

As a devoted fan of New York-style pizza, stepping into Amici Pizza in Tempe felt like a delightful culinary pilgrimage. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pies and those irresistible garlic knots—trust me, they’re a must-have!

I indulged in a classic slice, which boasted a delightful fold and a perfect balance of crispy yet chewy crust. With each bite, I was whisked away to the bustling streets of New York, where the pizza is an art form. Let’s not overlook their appetizing wings—tender, flavorful, and the perfect companion to my pie.

However, be prepared for a bit of a wait during peak hours; it’s no surprise that a place with such heart in every slice draws a crowd. Thankfully, the friendly service makes the wait feel just a tad shorter. All in all, Amici Pizza is a delightful haven for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza. With its mouthwatering offerings, it’s clear that Amici is firmly cemented as one of Tempe’s best-kept pizza secrets!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Chandler.

My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - Arcadia (Catering Available)

Highlights
Best NY Style pizza in Arizona
Crispy edges, perfect undercarriage
Clean kitchen, precise cooking
Comfy vibes, small business
Delicious cheesecake available

Stepping into My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria – Arcadia felt like entering a cozy slice of New York right in Tempe. The moment I walked in, the clean kitchen and the inviting aromas set the stage for what I hoped would be a remarkable pizza experience.

I ordered their signature NY-style pizza, and let me tell you—the crispy edges combined with a perfectly cooked undercarriage made each bite a delight. I couldn't resist the urge to uncover the intricate flavors of the homemade sauce that danced deliciously with the gooey cheese. This pizza is a testament to their dedication; it truly might just be the best NY-style pizza in Arizona.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere is warm, with an unmistakable small business charm that makes you feel at home. The staff is friendly and clearly takes pride in their craft. And don't forget to leave room for dessert; their cheesecake is a must-try! All in all, My Slice of the Pie isn’t just a place to satisfy your pizza cravings—it's a celebration of good food and community. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Old Town Scottsdale.

Night Owl Pizza & Drinks Scottsdale

Highlights
Retro skate vibe
Great pizza options
Awesome back patio
Fun pinball machine decor
Affordable happy hour

When I walked into Night Owl Pizza & Drinks Scottsdale, I was immediately struck by its retro skate vibe—a delightful throwback that felt vibrant and welcoming. As I settled in, the fun pinball machine decor added an extra layer of charm that made the atmosphere even more inviting.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Their menu boasts an array of great pizza options, and I decided to go for a classic New York slice. Each bite was a perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese, just the way a true New Yorker would demand. The sauce had a delightful zest, truly elevating the overall experience. It's clear that the team here knows what they're doing!

One of the highlights of my visit was the awesome back patio, an ideal spot to savor a slice while soaking in the Arizona sun. And for those looking to enjoy a great deal, their affordable happy hour made it easy to sample a few different toppings without breaking the bank.

In a city bustling with pizza options, Night Owl stands out for its playful spirit and authentic flavors. If you're in Tempe, this place is a must-visit for pizza lovers!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Scottsdale.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Highlights
Coal brick-oven pizza
Perfect for sharing
Classic Italian aesthetic
Incomparable pizza quality
Excellent customer service

Grimaldi's Pizzeria in Tempe is nothing short of a delightful revelation for any pizza aficionado. As I stepped inside, I was instantly struck by the classic Italian aesthetic, reminiscent of the charming pizzerias of New York. The inviting ambiance set the stage for what I can only describe as a pizza pilgrimage.

When it comes to their offerings, the coal brick-oven pizza truly steals the show. Each slice emanates a crispy, yet chewy crust—an exquisite balance that is delightfully hard to find elsewhere. I was particularly impressed by the incomparable pizza quality; each topping seemed to sing in harmony with the robust tomato sauce and perfectly melted cheese. The only problem? You’ll want to share, but good luck keeping your slices safe in the face of such temptation!

Moreover, the excellent customer service only added to the experience, enhancing the overall charm of the meal. Grimaldi's Pizzeria took my taste buds on a joyful journey—one that I’m sure will draw me back for another visit soon. If you’re searching for authentic New York pizza in Tempe, look no further; Grimaldi’s is an unequivocal gem!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Scottsdale.

Venezia's Pizza

Venezia's Pizza in Tempe is a delightful gem that truly brings the essence of New York to the desert. The moment I walked in, the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and rich tomato sauce greeted me like an old friend. Their thin, crispy crust strikes the perfect balance between chewiness and crunch, while the toppings are generously layered—especially the pepperoni, which has just the right amount of spice. Each bite felt like a mini-vacation to the East Coast. If you’re craving a slice that transports you to the bustling streets of NYC, look no further than Venezia's! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best burger in Tempe.

Gus's New York Pizza

Gus's New York Pizza in Tempe truly transports you to the bustling streets of NYC with each bite. The crust strikes a perfect balance—crispy yet chewy, bearing the classic fold that every New Yorker loves. Topped generously with rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, the flavors dance on your palate. I indulged in a slice of pepperoni, and wow, the spicy kick paired beautifully with the cheese. The ambiance is casual and friendly, making it a fantastic spot for a delicious pizza night. If you're craving a slice that’s both authentic and enjoyable, Gus's is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Costa Mesa.

Clockwork Pizza

Upon entering Clockwork Pizza, I was instantly welcomed by the warm aroma of fresh dough and simmering sauce. Their New York-style slices boast a perfectly crispy crust that has just the right amount of chew. I indulged in their classic cheese pizza, where gooey, rich mozzarella melded beautifully with their zesty tomato sauce. Each bite was a delightful balance of flavors that transported me straight to the streets of Manhattan. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff added to the experience, making it an exceptional spot for both locals and newcomers. If you’re hunting for authentic NY pizza in Tempe, this gem is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clairemont Mesa.

Otto Pizza

Stepping into Otto Pizza, I was greeted by the alluring aroma of freshly baked dough that instantly transported me to the streets of New York. Their thin, crisp crust was a masterclass in balance—perfectly chewy yet satisfyingly crunchy. Each slice was generously topped with rich tomato sauce and a blend of gooey mozzarella that danced on my palate. The classic Margherita was an homage to simplicity, showcasing quality ingredients. The charming vibe and friendly staff made my visit unforgettable. If you’re searching for a slice of authentic New York in Tempe, Otto Pizza should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Scottsdale.