The Absolute Best Cheesecake in Gilbert [Updated 2025]

You see, cheesecake isn’t just a dessert; it’s a passion that runs deep in my veins. After indulging in countless slices across twelve of the top spots in town, I’ve developed a palate that can distinguish between a mediocre piece and one that sends you straight to dessert heaven.

Trust me, I’ve tasted the good, the bad, and the oh-so-amazing, and I’m here to give you the scoop. Whether you’re a die-hard cheesecake lover or just looking for that perfect slice to satisfy your sweet tooth, I’ve got the insider knowledge to steer you toward the crème de la crème of Gilbert’s cheesecake offerings. Let’s dive into these delectable treats!

The Great Gadsby Bakery

Highlights
Huge selection of treats
Rich and moist cakes
Delicious cookies and cream
Adorable cafe ambiance
Outdoor seating available

Review of The Great Gadsby Bakery

From the moment I set foot in The Great Gadsby Bakery, I felt like I had entered a dessert wonderland. This charming establishment boasts a huge selection of treats, but let's focus on the star of the show: the cheesecake. The rich and moist cakes are simply divine, and the cookies and cream variant left me with a grin plastered on my face.

Every bite was a perfect blend of flavors, striking that elusive balance between sweetness and creaminess. The texture was spot on—smooth and velvety, melting in my mouth. I also appreciate the bakery's adorable café ambiance; it’s the kind of cozy spot that invites you to linger over a slice of cheesecake and a steaming cup of coffee. And if you're feeling adventurous, grab a seat outside to enjoy the pleasant Gilbert weather.

In short, if you're on the hunt for the best cheesecake in town, The Great Gadsby Bakery is a must-visit. Their dedication to quality and taste makes each visit an unforgettable experience, and I can’t wait to return for my next slice of bliss.

You might also want to check out the best cheesecake in Mesa.

Whisk & Paddle Bakeshop

Highlights
Stunning wedding cakes
Delicious bite-sized desserts
Beautifully crafted pastries
Highly recommended for events
Great team to work with

Whisk & Paddle Bakeshop is a delightful gem tucked away in Gilbert, and my visit there was nothing short of enchanting. Known for their stunning wedding cakes and beautifully crafted pastries, this bakeshop also excels in the art of cheesecake. As soon as I stepped in, I was greeted by the heavenly aroma of baked goods that set the stage for a truly memorable tasting experience.

I opted for their signature cheesecake, and it was a slice of pure bliss. The texture was remarkably smooth and creamy, melting in my mouth with every bite. The flavors were well-balanced, with just the right amount of sweetness that left me wanting more—truly a dessert lover's paradise!

What sets Whisk & Paddle apart is not just the cheesecake, but the fantastic team behind it. Their passion for baking shines brightly, and they are ever so accommodating, making it a pleasure to work with them whether for personal indulgence or special events.

If you’re looking for a dessert that will steal the show, this bakeshop is a top contender. Treat yourself to their cheesecake, and I promise you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Mesa.

Prep and Pastry

Highlights
Friendly and warm atmosphere
Quick, friendly service
Inventive menu options
Large portion sizes
Outdoor seating available

Review of Prep and Pastry

Stepping into Prep and Pastry is like being welcomed into a cozy, whimsical kitchen where every corner invites you to indulge. The friendly and warm atmosphere sets the perfect stage for the star of the show: their cheesecake. I was greeted promptly by the staff, who exuded an air of enthusiasm and knowledge about the menu—something I always appreciate.

As I settled down at one of their inviting tables, their inventive menu caught my eye. The cheesecake options here are not just your run-of-the-mill desserts; they’re creative masterpieces! I opted for the signature cheesecake, a delightful creation that was both rich and creamy, with a perfectly balanced crust. The large portion size made it a feast for the senses.

I also enjoyed the ability to dine outdoors, which enhanced my experience, allowing me to savor each bite while soaking in the sun. The quick, cheerful service ensured I never felt neglected, even as I savored every crumb of my dessert.

If you find yourself craving cheesecake, Prep and Pastry is a must-try. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Chandler.

FROSTAilS - Korean Dessert House

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming owner
Unique and refreshing deserts
Must-try soft cheesecake
Fresh ingredients used
Highly recommended by locals

FROSTAilS - Korean Dessert House offers a delightful twist on dessert, and their cheesecake is nothing short of remarkable. As I entered the space, I was immediately welcomed by the friendly owner, whose passion for creating unique and refreshing desserts is palpable.

The standout here is definitely the soft cheesecake, which is unlike any cheesecake I've tasted before. Made with fresh ingredients, each bite is an experience—both rich and light, allowing you to savor its delicate flavor without feeling weighed down. It's this attention to quality that truly sets FROSTAilS apart in Gilbert's dessert scene.

Listening to recommendations from locals, I decided to try this gem, and I can confidently say it was a fantastic decision. The cheesecake felt almost airlike, whispering sweet nothings as it melted on my tongue. This isn't your traditional dense cheesecake; instead, it presents a playful personality with every bite. If you’re on the hunt for the best cheesecake in Gilbert, I wholeheartedly suggest visiting FROSTAilS. You won’t just walk out with a satisfied sweet tooth; you’ll leave smiling, eager to return for more!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Cinnaholic

Highlights
Freshly baked cinnamon rolls
Generous portion sizes
Clean, modern atmosphere
Friendly and attentive staff
Variety of delicious options

Cinnaholic in Gilbert is a delightful haven for dessert lovers, and let me tell you, their cheesecake options are worth every bite! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a clean, modern atmosphere that instantly lifted my spirits. The friendly staff were eager to share their knowledge about their famous freshly baked cinnamon rolls—and how they cleverly incorporate cheesecake flavors into them!

I decided to try their cheesecake cinnamon roll, which was generously topped with creamy frosting and a hint of fruit preserves. The combination of warm, fluffy dough and creamy cheesecake essence was like a sweet hug for my taste buds! Each bite was an indulgence—rich yet light, striking that perfect balance that makes a dessert memorable.

One of the standout features at Cinnaholic is the variety they offer, catering to all kinds of sweet preferences. It's hard not to feel special when you're enjoying a treat crafted with such care. If you're in Gilbert and hunting for a cheesecake experience that’s both unique and satisfying, make sure to stop by Cinnaholic. Trust me; your palate will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Scottsdale.

Avec Amoore - Gluten free, with Love

Highlights
Delightful gluten-free options
Cozy and clean atmosphere
Welcoming and friendly service
Specializes in allergy-friendly
Made with love and care

As I stepped into Avec Amoore, I was greeted by a cozy and immaculate environment that immediately made me feel at home. This charming spot specializes in gluten-free treats, and their cheesecakes are a testament to their commitment: each slice is crafted with love and care.

I decided to indulge in their signature cheesecake, and let me tell you—what a delightful surprise! The texture was smooth and creamy, a perfect contrast to the buttery, gluten-free crust that crumbled beautifully with each bite. One of the standout features of this gem is how it manages to maintain that rich, indulgent feel while catering to those with dietary restrictions.

The staff was warm and friendly, eager to share their passion for creating delicious sweets that everyone can enjoy. It's clear that Avec Amoore isn’t just about satisfying cravings; they genuinely care about their clientele, offering allergy-friendly options without skimping on flavor.

If you're on the hunt for gluten-free cheesecake in Gilbert, look no further. I left with a happy heart and a satisfied palate, eagerly anticipating my next visit to this delightful, gluten-free haven. 🍰

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gilbert.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Highlights
Wedding day dessert perfection
Accommodating and friendly staff
Beautifully crafted desserts
Tasty Bundt cake options
Timely delivery and pickup

Nothing Bundt Cakes in Gilbert is an enchanting haven for dessert lovers, and their delightful cheesecakes certainly stand out in a sea of sugary offerings. From the moment I walked in, I felt enveloped by the warmth of their accommodating and friendly staff, who were genuinely eager to help me navigate their exquisite dessert selection.

What struck me most was the artistic craftsmanship of their cakes. Each piece seemed to bloom with creative flair, making it almost difficult to choose. But the rich, creamy texture of their cheesecake options won me over, delivering a taste that feels like a celebration of flavors on your palate!

In addition to their delectable treats, the timely delivery and pickup services further enhance the entire experience, making it ideal for those special moments—such as weddings or birthday parties. Each dessert feels like an intimate gift, perfect for sharing or simply indulging yourself.

For anyone looking to satisfy their cheesecake cravings, Nothing Bundt Cakes effortlessly combines beauty and flavor, making them a must-visit in Gilbert. Your sweet tooth will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Chandler.

Liberty Market

Highlights
Excellent downtown location
Attentive and friendly service
Diverse and tasty menu
Cozy and modern ambiance
Popular brunch spot

Liberty Market has carved a cozy niche in the heart of downtown Gilbert, and it's no wonder why. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm ambiance that perfectly captures the essence of a modern eatery while retaining its charming vintage touches. The attentive and friendly service made me feel right at home, setting the stage for my cheesecake adventure.

Now, let’s talk cheesecake! Liberty Market offers a selection that tantalizes the senses with both classic and creative flavors. I opted for their signature cheesecake, and it was a delightful triumph. The texture was decadently creamy, with just the right amount of sweetness. Each bite was a perfect blend of richness and lightness, making it dangerously easy to lose track of time while savoring this delectable treat.

The location itself is a gem—perfect for brunch before indulging in dessert—or as a charming stop during a leisurely day out. After my experience, it’s clear that Liberty Market's cheesecake deserves a spot on the list of Gilbert’s best. If you’re a cheesecake aficionado, don’t miss this unassuming yet delightful gem!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Chandler.

Wildflower

Highlights
Outstanding service
Delicious chipotle chicken sandwich
Amazing food selection
Repeat visit anticipation
Comforting potato cream cheese soup

Review of Wildflower in Gilbert

When I waltzed into Wildflower, I knew I was in for an adventure, but I didn't expect to be swept off my feet by their cheesecake! It was merely one of the delightful offerings that lured me in, but let me tell you, it was a showstopper. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the ideal spot for a relaxed dining experience. Once seated, I was treated to outstanding service that felt more like chatting with friends than just another meal order.

While waiting for my cheesecake, I indulged in their chipotle chicken sandwich paired with a bowl of comforting potato cream cheese soup – both were heavenly! But when the cheesecake arrived, it was game over. This slice of creamy goodness was velvety and rich, with a flavor profile that danced on my palate. The crust was perfectly crumbly, providing a delightful contrast to the creaminess above.

As I savored every bite, I couldn't help but feel a strong desire to return. If you’re on a quest for the best cheesecake in Gilbert, make sure Wildflower is on your list. Trust me, you’ll be coming back for seconds!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Old Town Scottsdale.

DECADENT MACARON

Highlights
Deliciously Unique Flavors
Cozy Indoor Seating
Great Coffee Selection
Friendly and Helpful Staff
Charming Ambiance

At DECADENT MACARON, I found myself enveloped in a charming ambiance that sets the perfect stage for indulging in their exquisite cheesecake offerings. The moment I stepped inside, the cozy seating and delightful decor made me feel right at home. But let's talk about the real star of the show: their deliciously unique cheesecake flavors!

I was particularly intrigued by their lavender honey and raspberry lemon cheesecake, both of which dance on the palate with vibrant notes. Each bite was a delightful experience, showcasing a creamy texture that effortlessly melted in my mouth.

Additionally, the friendly and helpful staff truly enhanced my visit. They guided me through the menu with enthusiasm and offered valuable recommendations, ensuring I made the most of my cheesecake journey. Oh, and if you enjoy coffee, their selection pairs beautifully with the desserts, elevating the experience even further.

In my quest to find the best cheesecake in Gilbert, DECADENT MACARON undoubtedly stands out as a must-visit. If you’re looking for a sweet escape, this charming spot serves up more than just cheesecakes; it offers pure bliss in every bite.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Scottsdale.

The Gilbert House

Highlights
Charming outdoor seating
Friendly and attentive staff
Relaxed, inviting atmosphere
Casual brunch with character
Delicious cinnamon roll

The moment I stepped into The Gilbert House, I was enveloped by a warm and inviting atmosphere that practically beckoned me to take a seat in their charming outdoor seating area. The casual vibe is perfect for brunch, where I found the staff to be not just friendly but also exceptionally attentive.

Now, let’s talk cheesecake! I ordered their signature cheesecake, a delightful creation that balances velvety smoothness with a subtle sweetness. Each bite melted in my mouth, making it clear that this isn't your average dessert. The rich flavor was well-complemented by a graham cracker crust that had just the right crunch, creating a delightful contrast in textures.

Before I left, I couldn’t resist sampling their delicious cinnamon roll—a perfect companion to the cheesecake. Overall, my visit to The Gilbert House was an experience worth savoring. This gem in Gilbert proves that great sweetness doesn’t just come from desserts; it also stems from the charming ambiance and the friendly service. If you’re on the hunt for the best cheesecake in Gilbert, this spot should undoubtedly be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Scottsdale.

Toasted Mallow

Toasted Mallow is a delightful gem in Gilbert, where sweet dreams come true. I indulged in their s'mores cheesecake, a playful twist that combines creamy decadence with a hint of toasted marshmallow. The crust was wonderfully crunchy, contrasting perfectly with the luscious filling. Each bite was a heavenly experience, leaving me craving more.

The whimsical atmosphere of the café adds to its charm, making it an inviting spot for dessert lovers. If you're on a quest for a unique cheesecake that delivers both fun and flavor, Toasted Mallow is an absolute must-try! You won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Tempe.