The Absolute Best Italian Food in Gilbert [Updated 2025]

Trust me, if you’re craving authentic Italian flavors, you’re in for a treat! I’ve scoured every corner of Gilbert, indulging in cheesy pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and decadent tiramisu at 12 top-notch locations. Each bite has been a delicious journey, and I can’t wait to share my favorites with you.

Having lived here and savored the local dining scene, I’ve developed a keen palate for what makes Italian cuisine truly special. Whether you’re a fan of traditional dishes or looking for something with a modern twist, I've got the scoop on where to go for an unforgettable meal. So, let’s dive into this culinary adventure together!

Crust Simply Italian Gilbert

Highlights
Amazing service by Natalie
Delicious fried calamari
Outstanding eggplant parmigiana
Special offers for occasions
Cozy outdoor dining experience

Crust Simply Italian Gilbert truly captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine right in the heart of Gilbert. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the warm, inviting atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for a casual meal or a special occasion. The service was impeccable, thanks to my server, Natalie, who seemed to know the menu inside and out.

I kicked off my meal with a plate of their delicious fried calamari. It was perfectly crisp and not overly greasy, served alongside a zesty marinara that made every bite a delight. For my main course, I opted for the outstanding eggplant parmigiana. The layers of tender eggplant, rich tomato sauce, and melted cheese created a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate.

What I appreciated most was Crust's focus on community; they offer special deals for gatherings, perfect for celebrating life's little moments.

To top off my visit, their cozy outdoor dining area was the cherry on top of an already delightful experience. If you’re craving Italian food in Gilbert, I highly recommend paying a visit to Crust Simply Italian—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Mesa.

Postino East

Highlights
Great selection of drinks
Busy but fast seating
Good food worth the visit
Service can improve
Family-friendly atmosphere

Postino East in Gilbert is a delightful spot that tantalizes your taste buds while offering a vibrant atmosphere. As I stepped inside, the buzz of conversation mingled with the aroma of Italian delicacies, creating an inviting ambiance that made my mouth water. The restaurant offers a great selection of drinks, which perfectly complemented the flavors on our table.

I have to say, the food was definitely worth the visit. The carefully curated menu showcases a blend of classic and modern Italian dishes that are sure to please. My taste buds danced when I savored their bruschetta—a testament to the chef's knack for using fresh, high-quality ingredients. However, I did notice that the service could use a bit of improvement, as the busy atmosphere made it challenging to catch our server's attention at times.

Despite the bustling environment, the seating turned out to be fast, which I appreciated for a dining experience that felt both family-friendly and lively. All in all, if you’re on the hunt for delectable Italian fare in Gilbert, Postino East is definitely a must-visit destination worth every bite! Mangia!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Mira Mesa.

Acqua Di' Mare

Highlights
Romantic Amalfi Coast atmosphere
Exquisite food presentation
Owner's personal dedication
Delicious pasta and calamari
Top-notch service experience

Acqua Di' Mare in Gilbert is nothing short of a culinary gem! From the moment I entered, I was swept away by the romantic Amalfi Coast atmosphere—think twinkling lights and soft music that whisk you straight to Italy. The decor sets the perfect stage for what is to come.

As I settled into my seat, the food presentation left me utterly enchanted. Each dish was a masterpiece that seemed almost too beautiful to eat. I opted for their house-made pasta and a side of fried calamari, both dishes bursting with vibrant flavors and freshness. The pasta was cooked to perfection, draped in a sauce that was both rich and delightful, while the calamari was light and crispy, paired wonderfully with a zesty dipping sauce.

What truly elevates the experience here is the owner's personal dedication to crafting authentic Italian dishes. You feel it in every bite! Complementing the unrivaled dining experience is the top-notch service, where each staff member is genuinely attentive, ensuring your visit is remarkable.

In summary, Acqua Di' Mare isn’t just about food; it’s about an experience that lingers long after the last bite. If you’re in Gilbert, don’t miss this enchanting culinary journey!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Costa Mesa.

Baci Italian Bistro

Highlights
Accommodating staff
Large food portions
Beautiful private patio
Fair pricing
Delicious food

Baci Italian Bistro: A Culinary Embrace

My recent visit to Baci Italian Bistro was nothing short of delightful! From the moment I stepped inside, I was warmly greeted by the accommodating staff who made me feel right at home. As I scanned the menu, the generous portion sizes instantly caught my attention—this place does not skimp on your plate!

I found the atmosphere charming, and the beautiful private patio was an inviting option for al fresco dining. The lovely ambiance paired perfectly with the tantalizing dishes I was eager to try. I opted for their signature pasta dish, and oh my, each bite was a flavor explosion that transported me straight to Italy.

One of the highlights was the fair pricing, especially for the quality of food served. It’s hard to beat that combination of exceptional taste and value!

If you're hunting for a place that encapsulates authentic Italian cuisine with a dash of Gilbert’s warmth, I wholeheartedly recommend Baci Italian Bistro. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a culinary embrace that leaves you wanting more!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Chandler.

Pesto's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar

Highlights
Delicious mushroom pasta
Moderate price point
Good portion sizes
Fresh, flavorful iced tea
Better pasta than pizza

Pesto's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar is a delightful gem that's sure to win your heart—and your taste buds. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that beckoned me to savor each moment. I couldn't resist ordering the mushroom pasta, and let me tell you, it was a culinary experience I won't soon forget. Each bite was a harmonious blend of al dente pasta and perfectly sautéed mushrooms, enveloped in a rich, creamy sauce that danced on my palate.

The portion sizes are generous without being overwhelming, making it easy to enjoy a hearty meal without the dreaded food coma. And speaking of enjoyable, their fresh iced tea is the perfect complement, refreshing and flavorful without being too sweet—a rare find!

While pizza often steals the spotlight in Italian cuisine, Pesto's pasta truly shines. With a moderate price point, dining here feels like a treat without breaking the bank. If you're on the hunt for delectable Italian dishes, I highly recommend Pesto's; it has swiftly become one of my favorite spots in Gilbert. Go, indulge, and discover your new obsession!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Society

Highlights
Homemade pasta to die for
Perfect for date nights
Delicious menu options
Trendy ambiance and decor
Great happy hour selection

Society in Gilbert is nothing short of a culinary treasure. From the moment I stepped inside, I felt enveloped by a trendy ambiance that screams modern Italian charm. The decor is sleek yet inviting, perfect for a cozy date night or a lively gathering with friends.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the homemade pasta. I can confidently say it’s to die for! Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, showcasing the chef’s skill and passion for authentic Italian cuisine. The variety on the menu is truly impressive, catering to a wide range of tastes. Whether you’re in the mood for a rich, creamy sauce or a light, zesty dish, Society has you covered.

A special shout-out must go to their happy hour selection. The drink options are just as exciting as the food, making it the perfect spot to unwind after a long day. I left Society feeling like I had a rendezvous with Italy itself, and I’m eager to return for another round of those irresistible noodles. If you’re in Gilbert and craving Italian, don’t miss the chance to dine at this gem!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Scottsdale.

Eatalio Pasta & Wine

Highlights
Fantastic food and service
Attentive and friendly staff
Extensive menu options
Great for families
Inviting atmosphere

Visiting Eatalio Pasta & Wine in Gilbert was a delightful culinary adventure, where my love for Italian food was not only satisfied but elevated! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The interiors are captivating, setting the perfect backdrop for what I hoped would be a memorable meal.

The attention to detail from the staff was remarkable; they were not just friendly but genuinely attentive, effortlessly guiding me through their extensive menu options. With everything from handmade pasta to a curated selection of wines, I felt as though I was in for a treat. I opted for their signature dish, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of spectacular. The flavors danced on my palate, showcasing classic Italian craftsmanship.

What truly stood out was how Eatalio caters to families, creating a warm environment where everyone can enjoy the rich flavors of Italy together. If you find yourself in Gilbert and are craving something authentic, make sure you stop by Eatalio Pasta & Wine. You'll leave with a smile and a full belly, dreaming of your next visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gilbert.

North Italia

My visit to North Italia in Gilbert was nothing short of enchanting! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warm ambiance and the delightful aroma of fresh ingredients. I couldn't resist trying their mouthwatering pizzas, especially the classic Margherita, which boasted a perfect balance of flavors. The homemade pasta dazzled my taste buds, particularly the ricotta gnocchi—soft, pillowy, and simply divine. The attentive service added to the overall charm. North Italia truly captures the essence of Italian dining, making it a must-visit for anyone craving authentic and delectable dishes in Gilbert. Don't miss it!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Chandler.

Salerno's

Tucked away in the heart of Gilbert, Salerno's is a delightful surprise for any Italian food lover. As I stepped inside, the ambiance whisked me to a cozy trattoria in Italy. The homemade pasta is a standout—each bite bursts with flavor. Their signature marinara is rich and perfectly balanced, making the perfect canvas for their tender meatballs. It's hard to resist the gelato for dessert; it’s so creamy, it feels like a warm hug on a cool day. If you're after authentic, hearty Italian flavors, Salerno's is the spot that will leave you dreaming of Italy! 🍝✨

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Chandler.

Picazzo's Healthy Italian Kitchen

At Picazzo's Healthy Italian Kitchen, I was delighted by their fresh twist on traditional Italian cuisine. The vibrant atmosphere immediately set a cheerful tone, inviting me to explore their menu. I opted for the Zucchini Noodles tossed in a rich marinara, and each bite was a delightful dance of flavors. The Cauliflower Crust Pizza was not only a healthier option but equally indulgent, topped with vibrant vegetables and a sprinkle of fresh basil. Their commitment to wholesome ingredients without sacrificing taste is commendable. If you're seeking a guilt-free treat, Picazzo's is a must-visit for a joyfully delicious experience in Gilbert!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Old Town Scottsdale.

The Sicilian Butcher

As a passionate food enthusiast, my recent venture to The Sicilian Butcher in Gilbert was nothing short of delightful. The ambiance radiates a rustic charm, perfectly complementing the mouthwatering menu. I indulged in their handmade meatballs, which were tender, savory bursts of Italian tradition. The pasta—ah, perfection! Cooked al dente, it paired beautifully with their rich sauces. And let’s not forget the impressive selection of charcuterie, ideal for sharing (or not!). If you're searching for an authentic experience that tantalizes the senses, The Sicilian Butcher is a must-visit. Each bite will leave you saying, “Mamma mia!” 🎉

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Scottsdale.

Brio Italian Grille

Brio Italian Grille in Gilbert stole my heart (and taste buds) with its charming ambiance and mouthwatering menu. The pasta primavera was a delightful dance of seasonal veggies and perfectly cooked noodles, all enveloped in a light garlic sauce. I couldn't resist the tiramisu for dessert; it was an indulgent end to my meal that whisked me away to Italy with every bite. The staff was attentive without being intrusive, making the overall experience feel both special and relaxed. If you’re craving authentic Italian flavors, Brio is a must-visit gem that won’t disappoint!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Scottsdale.