Tempe's Best Pies [Updated 2026]

You can imagine my delight as I dove into the delightful world of Tempe’s pie scene, sampling sweet and savory treasures across 12 top-notch locations. Trust me, it’s been a delicious adventure filled with flaky crusts and mouthwatering fillings—each bite a testament to local craftsmanship.

With my taste buds finely tuned and a decade of pie-tasting experience under my belt, I’m here to take you on a journey through the best this vibrant town has to offer. Whether you crave classic fruit pies or something a bit more adventurous, I’ve uncovered hidden gems and beloved favorites that will make your dessert dreams come true. Let’s dig in!

Honeymoon Sweets European Bakery

Highlights
Amazing dessert flavors
Unwelcoming atmosphere
Poor customer service
Concerns about food freshness
Disappointing experience overall

Honeymoon Sweets European Bakery: A Pie Adventure

My journey to discover the best pies in Tempe led me to Honeymoon Sweets European Bakery, and what an adventure it was! Upon entering, I was greeted by an enticing display of desserts, bursting with a spectrum of flavors that promised delightful moments. However, my excitement quickly wavered. The atmosphere, though quaint, felt somewhat unwelcoming, leaving me conflicted as I eyed their tantalizing pie selection.

I opted for a slice of their signature fruit pie, eager for a taste of bliss. Unfortunately, the customer service was less than stellar. The staff seemed preoccupied, resulting in an experience that lacked warmth. While the bakery boasts a reputation for exquisite flavors, I did notice lingering doubts regarding the pies' freshness—a key factor in any pie lover's heart.

In the end, my visit to Honeymoon Sweets was disappointing given my high expectations. While the flavors had potential, the overall experience left me wanting more. Tempe has many delightful pastry spots to explore, and I encourage you to check out others before settling down at this one. After all, pie should be a joyful celebration, not just a sweet escape!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Mesa.

Pie Snob Chandler

Highlights
24-hour pie vending machine
Rotating selection of flavors
Fresh and flavorful slices
Large portion sizes
Attentive and quick service

Review of Pie Snob Chandler

Stepping into Pie Snob Chandler felt like entering a sweet sanctuary devoted to all things pie. With their innovative 24-hour pie vending machine, I immediately knew this place was serious about satisfying late-night cravings. And trust me, I took full advantage! The vending machine offers a rotating selection of flavors, which is both exciting and slightly overwhelming—as if choosing a favorite child.

I indulged in a generous slice of their signature pecan pie. The crust was perfectly flaky, contrasting beautifully with the rich, nutty filling that was bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful adventure, leaving me wanting more. The large portion sizes ensured that my dessert dreams were fulfilled without leaving me unsatisfied—definitely a win in my book!

What truly set my visit apart was the attentive and quick service. The staff were clearly passionate about their pies, eagerly sharing recommendations that made my experience even more enjoyable. If you find yourself in Tempe and are yearning for a pie that will make your taste buds dance, look no further than Pie Snob Chandler. It’s a slice of heaven that will leave you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Chandler.

PIEfection Chandler

Highlights
Triple Berry Pie Excellence
Adorable Shop Atmosphere
Quality Flaky Crust
Savory Pies Available
Individual Slices Offered

PIEfection Chandler in Tempe is a little slice of heaven that beckons from the moment you step inside. The adorable shop atmosphere radiates warmth, making it an inviting spot to indulge your pie cravings. Their Triple Berry Pie is a standout that perfectly balances sweetness and tartness, bringing a delightful burst of fruit with every bite.

What truly sets PIEfection apart is their quality flaky crust. It’s the kind that shatters beautifully upon first contact, revealing a luscious filling that's practically begging for consideration. Whether I was sampling a slice of savory pie or the renowned berry variety, I was continuously impressed by the dedication to craftsmanship in each dish.

The fun twist here is that they offer individual slices, allowing you to explore various flavors without the commitment of a full pie—though I can’t lie; once you taste them, you might wish you had brought home a whole pie! Each visit feels like a mini celebration of all things pie, and I wholeheartedly recommend PIEfection Chandler as a must-visit spot for pie lovers in Tempe. Give your taste buds a treat—they’ll be infinitely grateful!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Gilbert.

BEG Bakery & Creamery and P.A.R.M. Italia

Highlights
Butter-free and gluten-free
Wide variety of desserts
Insanely delicious plant-based
Friendly and welcoming owners
Spotless and visually appealing

Let me just say, my taste buds had a field day at BEG Bakery & Creamery! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and welcoming owners, who are as passionate about pies as I am. The butter-free and gluten-free options make it a treasure trove for those with dietary restrictions. I dove headfirst into their plant-based pies, and let me tell you, they were insanely delicious! It’s a delightful surprise to enjoy such rich flavors while maintaining a wholesome profile.

Then there's P.A.R.M. Italia, where traditional meets modern. Their pie offerings are a perfect example of how Italian heritage can take the humble pie to exquisite heights. The crust is perfectly flaky and encases an array of fillings that are a feast for the senses. The cleanliness and visual appeal of the shop also added to the experience—it's a charming atmosphere that truly complements the artistry of their baked goods.

If you're in Tempe, you owe it to yourself to check out these two gems. Each bite is a testament to the love and creativity poured into making the best pies in town! 🍰

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Scottsdale.

Buttered Up Bakery - Mesa

Highlights
Freshly baked pastries
Quaint small business ambiance
Delicious breakfast sandwiches
Unique croissant pizza crust
Warm cherry pie tarts

Stepping into Buttered Up Bakery - Mesa felt like wandering into a cozy haven of delightful aromas and baked bliss. Nestled in the heart of Tempe, this quaint spot captures the essence of a cherished local bakery. The moment I walked in, the warm scent of freshly baked pastries enveloped me; it was impossible to resist!

I decided to indulge in one of their stellar offerings: the warm cherry pie tarts. Oh, what a treat! The crust was buttery and golden, cradling a generous helping of tart cherries that burst with flavor. Each bite was an orchestra of sweet-tart harmony that left me craving more.

In addition to their amazing pies, Buttered Up Bakery also serves up delicious breakfast sandwiches that are genuinely worthy of a detour! And let’s not forget their unique croissant pizza crust – a playful twist that shows off their creativity and passion for baking.

If you’re on a quest for delicious pies in Tempe, Buttered Up Bakery is a must-visit where delectable flavors meet heartwarming ambiance. It's a delightful escape for any pie lover or casual passerby alike!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Pie Snob Arcadia

Highlights
Cute shop ambiance
Delicious gelato options
Great service
Favorite flavors: Keylime
Affordable prices

Pie Snob Arcadia is a delightful gem nestled in Tempe, and stepping inside feels like entering a cozy haven for pie lovers. The cute shop ambiance immediately sets the mood for indulgence, with charming decor that complements the sweet offerings beautifully. Among the tempting options, my taste buds were beckoned by their standout Key Lime pie, which is a must-try for any citrus enthusiast. The balance of tartness and sweetness danced perfectly with the velvety texture—an absolute delight!

What adds to the allure of this establishment is not just the pies, but their scrumptious gelato options, perfect for pairing with a slice or enjoying on its own. The service was attentive without being intrusive, making me feel right at home. Plus, the affordable prices meant I could indulge without guilt, leaving room for a second slice (or maybe even a third!).

All in all, Pie Snob Arcadia encapsulates a whimsical yet professional approach to pie-making, and if you're in Tempe, it should definitely be on your list. Don't miss out on this wonderful experience—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Scottsdale.

Great Harvest Bread Co.

Great Harvest Bread Co. delivered a delightful surprise with their hands-on approach to baking. Their pies, especially the fresh berry pie, burst with vibrant flavors and a perfectly flaky crust that dances in your mouth. Each bite is a harmonious blend of sweetness, with the berries tasting just-picked. What truly sets them apart is their commitment to using natural ingredients, ensuring every slice feels like a loving hug. The cozy atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for a sweet escape. If you’re in Tempe, don’t miss out on this pie paradise!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gilbert.

Cornish Pasty Co

The Cornish Pasty Co. is a delightful gem that brings a slice of England to Tempe! Their signature pasties are a savory revelation, bursting with rich fillings like the classic steak and ale or the decadent vegetarian option packed with vibrant veggies and cheese. The flaky crust is simply divine, a perfect companion to the hearty interiors. I savored each bite, and the cozy, quirky atmosphere made the experience even more enjoyable. If you’re on the hunt for a deliciously unique pie, this spot is a must. Grab a pasty and immerse yourself in pie perfection!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Chandler.

Experiment Coffee and Pastry

Tucked away in Tempe, Experiment Coffee and Pastry is an absolute gem! Their blueberry pie is a burst of flavor, with a flaky crust that cradles plump, juicy berries. Each bite is a delightful dance of sweet and tart, that leaves you longing for more. The cozy ambiance makes it a perfect spot to enjoy a slice alongside their expertly crafted coffee. When it comes to pie perfection, this local spot has certainly mastered the art. If you’re a pie lover, let your taste buds embark on this whimsical adventure at Experiment—it’s worth every delicious crumb!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Chandler.

Golden Restaurant & Bakery

At Golden Restaurant & Bakery, the charm of cozy nostalgia embraces you the moment you step inside. Their signature apple pie deserves a standing ovation—each bite reveals a delightful balance of tart and sweet, harmonizing with a perfectly flaky crust. The coconut cream pie is a luscious cloud of coconut bliss, topped with dreamy whipped cream that nearly made me swoon. The atmosphere hums with warmth, making it an ideal spot for comfort food lovers. If you’re searching for a slice of happiness in Tempe, don’t miss this hidden gem. It’s truly a pie paradise!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Old Town Scottsdale.

Wake N Bakery Tempe

I recently indulged in a delectable slice of pie at Wake N Bakery Tempe, and let me tell you, it was a slice of heaven! This charming spot beckons with the aroma of freshly baked goods, and their pies are no exception. I tried the signature blueberry pie, which was bursting with juicy berries and encased in a buttery, flaky crust. The comfortable ambiance invites you to linger over your treat, and the friendly staff adds to the warm experience. If you're in Tempe and seeking a heavenly pie, look no further than Wake N Bakery—it's a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Scottsdale.

Quiches & Pies

During my recent visit to Quiches & Pies in Tempe, I was instantly enchanted by the cozy atmosphere that felt like a warm hug. The pies here are nothing short of delightful, with flaky crusts that crunch perfectly beneath your fork. I indulged in a savory chicken pot pie—each bite was a symphony of tender chicken and vibrant veggies. The highlight, however, was the mango peach pie, bursting with fresh, tangy sweetness. It's a dessert that dances on your palate! If you’re searching for the best pies in Tempe, make sure to treat yourself to a slice of heaven at Quiches & Pies.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Scottsdale.